Welcome to the new Macworld.com
#4
Posted 14 December 2007 - 12:39 AM
Jason,
While I like the new colors and button styles, I don't like the general apperance at all. A lot of wasted space, a lot of advertisement (either for articles on MacWorld, or adds from other sources). I did some comparison with the old and new design on a 23" Cinema Display: Old design: info gets about 30%, the rest is advertisement and wasted space. New design: 20% information. On a 15" MacBook Pro it is even worse: old: 20% information, new: 5% information. But information is why people come to your site.
Would you really go to a web site which gives you 95% advertisement and navigation ?
Unless things change I don't think you will see me regularily again on your web site.
Bye bye and have a good time.
Message was edited by: DonC, just changed some typos
While I like the new colors and button styles, I don't like the general apperance at all. A lot of wasted space, a lot of advertisement (either for articles on MacWorld, or adds from other sources). I did some comparison with the old and new design on a 23" Cinema Display: Old design: info gets about 30%, the rest is advertisement and wasted space. New design: 20% information. On a 15" MacBook Pro it is even worse: old: 20% information, new: 5% information. But information is why people come to your site.
Would you really go to a web site which gives you 95% advertisement and navigation ?
Unless things change I don't think you will see me regularily again on your web site.
Bye bye and have a good time.
Message was edited by: DonC, just changed some typos
#6
Posted 14 December 2007 - 06:23 AM
Long-time Mac user (since '84) and long-time Macworld reader (since issue #1 with young Stevie on the cover). But I have found, for quite some time, that Macworld's home page was all over the place and, as a result, I never went there. Since Safari, I have used the RSS feed to the news summaries as my portal to Macworld. But that is all about to change.
The division of the site into Mac/iPod/iPhone is great. The User tabs based on reader votes is really useful. And the wider format is great. I like that the ads are keyed to the section--if you've always done this (by article?) it seems more prominent now than it did.
I plan on doing A LOT more exploring of the site--that has to be a major win for you guys to have a jaded site reader make such a comment.
Keep it up. best of luck.
The division of the site into Mac/iPod/iPhone is great. The User tabs based on reader votes is really useful. And the wider format is great. I like that the ads are keyed to the section--if you've always done this (by article?) it seems more prominent now than it did.
I plan on doing A LOT more exploring of the site--that has to be a major win for you guys to have a jaded site reader make such a comment.
Keep it up. best of luck.
#7
Posted 14 December 2007 - 06:29 AM
I agree with DonC regarding ad space. The first thing I noticed is the larger ads. Story text seems more confined with ads taking up way too much screen real estate.
And will I have to logon each time I visit? There didn't seem to be a check box to log me on automatically.
And will I have to logon each time I visit? There didn't seem to be a check box to log me on automatically.
#10
Posted 14 December 2007 - 08:31 AM
Hi. Not so much a comment on the new look which, so far I kinda like, but on the fact that I was not able to sign in under my old account. I tried everything I could think of but kept getting denied entry. I'm pretty sure I know what email, name and password I had before, but I even tried all variations and combinations my brain could come up with and nothing has worked. So, I created a new account, which i didn't want to have to do.
Has anyone else experienced problems logging in to the new site? Is there a better place I should be reporting this?
Has anyone else experienced problems logging in to the new site? Is there a better place I should be reporting this?
#11
Posted 14 December 2007 - 08:43 AM
I don't like your new look as well as the old one. IMHO the ads are more intrusive and make reading the articles more difficult, but I guess that's where you get the money to support the website. I couldn't find a "Print this article" button on the new page layout. I occasionally like to print the articles to a pdf file for future reference, especially Leopard info for use when I get around to installing it.



Sign In
Register
Help

MultiQuote