Quantcast
You are not logged in, click here to log in.
15 Replies Last post: Jan 21, 2005 4:40 PM by DPG4450Guy   1 2 Previous Next
Click to view DPG4450Guy's profile Enthusiast 1,856 posts since
Sep 14, 2003
Reply

Jan 19, 2005 10:25 AM

anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?

With the unfortunate disappearance of Symantec's Norton Utilities upon the release of Tiger,
I'm trying to find something that can repair files and still do what NU 8 and DW did for directory
issues.

ProSoft is a reputable company, so I'm optimistic about this.

I just can't live with TTP's slowwwness.
Reply
Click to view d00d's profile Macworld Editorial 12,136 posts since
Apr 24, 2001
1. Jan 19, 2005 10:41 AM in response to: DPG4450Guy
Re: anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?
In reply to:<hr />
With the unfortunate disappearance of Symantec's Norton Utilities upon the release of Tiger

<hr />
You say tomato (long a), I say tomato (short a)...

You say unfortunate, I say fortunate.

Click to view Grant_G's profile Old Hand 5,630 posts since
Jan 12, 2001
2. Jan 19, 2005 2:17 PM in response to: d00d
Re: anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?
You say DriveGenius 1.0, I say TechTool Pro 4.0.x. I know ... you've heard all that before. But the durn thing works, albeit very slowly if run from the CD. So in your situation with multiple Macs, I'd just put it on an external Firewire drive, small/portable with Panther --> Tiger on it and use it wherever needed. You could put DW on it too.

DriveGenius is a 1.0 -- TTP is proven. It's what I would go with (have, in fact).

G
Click to view nnager's profile Member 522 posts since
Feb 15, 2002
3. Jan 19, 2005 5:28 PM in response to: DPG4450Guy
No, but TechTool Pro 4.0.3 works well
As a volunteer beta tester, I donated my services before the public release of TTP 4.0.3 and there's a great deal this utility does and does well.

I just launched the application and here's a partial list of tests, repairs and procedures.

Hardware Tests: Cache, Clock, FireWire, Main Memory, Mathematics, Network, Processor, USB, Video Memory

Drive Tests: Disk Controller, Read Write, S.M.A.R.T., Surface Scan

Volume: Tests and Repairs Volume Structure

Files: 1. Tests Files 2. Tests and Repairs Finder Info

It also does Directory Maintenance (Micromat's equivalent of Alsoft's DiskWarrior "Rebuild Directory," and a whole bunch of other things.

On G4, I have it programmed to do SMART testing and automatic diagnostics of Volume Structure (they recommend half-hourly or hourly checks (I can't remember), but I just have it check both every 24 hours. And if it finds any problems, I gave it an email address to which to send me alerts. But because I clone my volumes on a regular rotation basis, I don't use the "Protection" feature that maintains invisible files of volume structure.

I have no affiliation whatsoever with Micromat other than as an unpaid volunteer beta tester, but--as is obvious--I've found TechTool Pro a must-have utility.

Respectfully, Norm
Click to view nnager's profile Member 522 posts since
Feb 15, 2002
4. Jan 19, 2005 5:34 PM in response to: DPG4450Guy
Launch while booted from another HD or eDrive
In reply to:<hr />
I just can't live with TTP's slowwwness.

<hr />
I don't. I do not launch it from a CD. I have it installed on two drives and it works fine from drive to drive. An option for any of your users is to install TTP's eDrive and launch TTP and Disk Utility from there. Much faster than a CD. Respectfully, Norm
Click to view albloom's profile Old Hand 2,251 posts since
Apr 21, 2004
5. Jan 20, 2005 3:23 AM in response to: DPG4450Guy
Re: anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?
I'm with most of the folks. I got a second TTP4 license
for Leslye's machine (not horribly expensive to add
licenses), set up both to run off eDrive, and don't
see any terrible slowness. And it's a great product.
Click to view Grant_G's profile Old Hand 5,630 posts since
Jan 12, 2001
7. Jan 20, 2005 10:34 AM in response to: DPG4450Guy
Re: anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?
If their comparison is off on so basic an item as price (see DiskWarrior, which lists for $80), I wonder if they're off in other areas as well? That said, I think trying to compare any of these products with DW is counter-productive. It has never been advertised as an all-encompassing disk utility. It only does one thing, but does it far better than anything else on the market.

If they would like me to review it for inclusion in the OS X Forum FAQ, I'd be happy to accept a gratis copy of Drive Genius.

G
Click to view d00d's profile Macworld Editorial 12,136 posts since
Apr 24, 2001
9. Jan 20, 2005 12:01 PM in response to: DPG4450Guy
Re: anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?
Didn't Grant say that when he said:
In reply to:<hr />
That said, I think trying to compare any of these products with DW is counter-productive. It has never been advertised as an all-encompassing disk utility. It only does one thing, but does it far better than anything else on the market.

<hr />
Click to view Grant_G's profile Old Hand 5,630 posts since
Jan 12, 2001
10. Jan 20, 2005 1:15 PM in response to: DPG4450Guy
Re: anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?
I think it's evident which way you're going to go. Give us the lowdown on how DG works for you, would you please? You know I'm interested.

G
Click to view Nobody's profile New Member 58,347 posts since
Oct 18, 2007
12. Jan 21, 2005 10:15 AM in response to: DPG4450Guy
Re: anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?
"I'm waiting for one of you to volunteer.

Or a review ... or something."


That may still not be sufficiently helpful; a lot of us have been warning about dangers of using Norton's DiskQuack long before its well deserved demise.

Click to view Nobody's profile New Member 58,347 posts since
Oct 18, 2007
14. Jan 21, 2005 3:54 PM in response to: DPG4450Guy
Re: anyone try Drive Genius 1.0 yet?
As someone already mentioned, NU is out of business for Macs so if your company still licenses NU from them, perhaps you have an exclusive and better than average version.

As for never having any problems with NU or accepting its shortcomings, I have seen some remarks by posters who never repair anything and claim to have no problems. I also know people who ride motorcycles without helmets, weave in and out of lanes and drive between lanes as they pass cars in adjacent lanes. They too are alive and have not had accidents but these observations do not change facts about the odds....