Quantcast
You are not logged in, click here to log in.
2 Replies Last post: Mar 3, 2005 10:25 AM by BigFatDuck  
Click to view UncleMarc's profile New Member 1 posts since
Mar 3, 2005
Reply

Mar 3, 2005 9:14 AM

Converting LPs to CDs

I need some advice, please:
I am trying to convert old LPs to CDsand my prime objective is Sound Quality!!
Later, I plan to do the same with old Advent C90 Chromium Dioxide cassette tapes.
So far, I have proceeded as described below, but I sense that Ive lost some sound quality the way Ive done it.

My equipment is a PE turntable with diamond needle connected via iMic to an Apple G-5 using System 10.3.7. Im playing the CDs on a Denon DCM 380 CD player through a Denon DRA 375 receiver to Advent speakers.


1.I used the $40 iMac (and Final Vinyl) to bring my LP audio into to my G-5. Would I have been better off if I had used Griffins $100 PowerWave?

2.I then moved the original audio files (AIFF) in to iTunes. When I burn CDs from iTunes, does iTunes use in its burning process its a) smaller, compressed file in iTunes or b) the original, uncompressed file in my Master Library folder kept elsewhere on my G-5? http://Im concerned that it used the compressed file.

3.Would I get more sound onto the CD by using Spin Doctor rather than iTunes?

4.In the burn process, am I better off burning at 52x (maximum speed for Verbatim discs) than, say, 16x? http://Ive tried an older Spin Doctor at 16x (its max.) and it does not seem to be as good.


How can I maximize my sound quality, starting from where I am?

Thanks for your help!

Reply
Click to view ftaok's profile Enthusiast 1,069 posts since
Jun 21, 2001
1. Mar 3, 2005 10:05 AM in response to: UncleMarc
Re: Converting LPs to CDs
In reply to:<hr />
2. I then moved the original audio files (AIFF) in to iTunes. When I burn CDs from iTunes, does iTunes use in its burning process its a) smaller, compressed file in iTunes or b) the original, uncompressed file in my Master Library folder kept elsewhere on my G-5? http://Im concerned that it used the compressed file.


<hr />
You say you moved the AIFF file into iTunes, then you say you kept the original file somewhere else. Which is it? iTunes is able to handle AIFF files, so if that is what is in the iTunes library, then a CD burned from iTunes won't lose any additional quality.

It sounds as though you've converted the original AIFF file into something else for iTunes. If this is the case, the CD burned from iTunes will not sound as good as the original AIFF file. Hard to say how much quality is lost, though.
Click to view BigFatDuck's profile Member 775 posts since
Sep 12, 2002
2. Mar 3, 2005 10:25 AM in response to: UncleMarc
Re: Converting LPs to CDs
oher than making sure you have your input volume levels where they should be to avoid too low or too high volume (resulting in clipping, that sort of thing), the only thing in that set up that would be making a noticeable loss in sound quality would be if you are using itunes to convert the music to a compressed format. check your itunes import settings, if it's set to mp3 or AAC then every file you drag in or import is being compressed and losing sound quality for the sake of saving space. i'm assuming this is the case and you're aware of the compression otherwise there would be no reason to keep a copy of the original file elsewhere on the computer, right? so to answer your question, how is itunes supposed to know you have a folder with the uncompressed music elsewhere on your computer? when you burn a cd from itunes it's using the files that are stored in the itunes music folder which unless you've changed the settings will be compressed files (mp3, AAC). i'll assume that you want to keep a compressed copy of the music in itunes for use on an ipod or something and that you don't want to keep the copy of full quality music in the itunes library for one reason or another. in that case you can either A) import the files again in itunes with the import settings changed to AIFF or Apple Lossless (good alternative to keeping full size files as backup), burn the cd and then delete the the newly imported full quality files out of itunes once you're done, or B) use the finder or Roxio Toast to burn a cd using the folder of full quality music you're keeping elsewhere on the drive.

i backed up a lot of my LP's several years ago using just the audio-in on my g4 tower and the free program Audacity. i then imported that music into itunes in Apple Lossless to be burned onto dvd for backup, and then converted those files to AAC and deleted the Lossless files off the computer to save space. sound quality is fine to my ears, but a little later in life i'll probably go through and re-do it all in super high quality once i get the right equipment, for the sake of preservation.