Quantcast
You are not logged in, click here to log in.
32 Replies Last post: Feb 20, 2007 12:16 PM by Jon Seff   1 2 3 Previous Next
Click to view Macworld.com's profile Enthusiast 1,900 posts since
Feb 6, 2004
Reply

Jan 22, 2007 2:00 PM

Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook questions

The ModBook, an Apple MacBook modified by Axiotron and OWC into a tablet computer running OS X, captured a lot of attention at Macworld Expo. Now Jonathan Seff has his hands on an early model. more
Reply
Click to view Drewboo's profile New Member 4 posts since
Aug 29, 2004
1. Jan 22, 2007 5:02 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook questions
No questions... just a comment that I'm totally jealous.



drewboo
Click to view tfrogh's profile New Member 46 posts since
Dec 3, 2004
2. Jan 22, 2007 5:09 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
How bright is the screen? How is it for glare when working outside. Does it get hot on your arm while holding it? Is the stylus input a joy or pain when surfing the web and entering data (logins/passwords). Have you written some lengthy emails with it? Are you answering these questions from it? Do you have click drag like a track pad?

That should get things started.

Tom
Click to view kevphil's profile New Member 6 posts since
Feb 21, 2006
3. Jan 22, 2007 5:13 PM in response to: tfrogh
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
How is the resolution? In short, what kind of poor man's Cintiq does it make?
Click to view OM_user's profile Member 649 posts since
Oct 13, 2004
4. Jan 22, 2007 5:27 PM in response to: kevphil
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
Poor man's Cintiq? Given the ModBook's "intro" pricing is $2199, and the Cintiq is $2499, it wouldn't exactly save you that much cash. If what you need is a display you can draw on, you may be better off spending a few hundred more on the Cintiq, since at least you know it was engineered specifically for that purpose. And the Cintiq most certainly has a larger display and higher resolution (21.3" 1600x1200) OWC doesn't list the resolution of the ModBook, just the size at 13.3", so I would guess it's the same as the MacBook's - 1280x800.

But I suppose a good question is how the tablet works in a drawing regard. If it works as well as a Cintiq, it might be worth it if you need the portability.
Personally I'd spend a little more and get the Cintiq if I needed that kind of solution.
Click to view daneb's profile Member 478 posts since
Dec 1, 2006
5. Jan 22, 2007 5:34 PM in response to: OM_user
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
It's the exact LCD that came with the MacBook isn't it? Just covered? Maybe I misunderstood. Do you think Apple with be making a tablet anytime in the future? I don't think their Multi-touch technology will just be used on a phone and maybe the new iPod interface...
Click to view Sunnyvale's profile New Member 8 posts since
Mar 21, 2006
6. Jan 22, 2007 5:44 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
A Couple items of interest:

(1) Is the screen sensitivity good enough for more than just
note taking, i.e., sketching or drawing block diagrams
that will not look overly bit-mapped. Maybe relates to
dots per inch of screen and stylus interaction.

(2) Is the screen about the right size for a tablet? Think
Apple has be investigating something smaller than a 13.3"
laptop size, based on articles, prior posts. Maybe a
shorthand/legal notetaking pad size?

(3) It seems the need is there for a tablet, however, the
pricing has always been the issue for many. Is this form
factor, pricing something that will work in the marketplace,
or is a "super" iPhone/iTablet make more sense from both
a pricing and usability point of view?
Click to view shoaf's profile New Member 57 posts since
Jun 22, 2005
7. Jan 22, 2007 5:45 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
I think I already know the answer to this, but can you rotate the screen (or more correctly, the display of the GUI elements) to portrait mode?

Also, how frustrating is it for non-character input? Like "Enter" or "Backspace/Delete"?

As much as I like the idea of a portable digital sketchbook, I have gotten extremely used to keyboard modifiers and commands... I'd really have to change my ways of doing things on something like this.
Click to view iJavaJoe's profile New Member 20 posts since
Jan 30, 2006
8. Jan 22, 2007 5:50 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook questions
The obvious question is how does it work with the likes of Photoshop, Illustrator, Painter or Sketchbook? Since it is a MacBook can you use a USB Keyboard/Mouse? Is it heavier or lighter then a regular MacBook? How is working with the screen? Is it matt or glossy? Does the unit loose connection to the Wacom tablet screen (that's why they put the reset button next to the power button)? Does the reset button reset the USB or just the Tablet connection? Have you been able to try any 3D applications (Poser, Maya, Carrara, etc.), how do they perform? Can you use any of the other Wacom pens with the ModBook?

How is the handwriting recognition? How easy is it to use the on-screen Keyboard?

Is there any type of cover that comes with the ModBook or will a case be required?

Comment: I wonder what they do with the keyboard from the MacBook? It would be very nice if they could turn that into a USB keyboard that comes with the ModBook!
Click to view stevko's profile New Member 1 posts since
Jan 22, 2007
9. Jan 22, 2007 5:53 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
The basic questions I have are as follows:

* I want to use this as a sketchbook; how do programs such as Photoshop, Painter, Curio and Sketchbook Pro work on this?
* How does the 256 level sensitivity affect any work?
* Is it easier or harder to work on this than with a regular laptop and a separate tablet?
* How hard is it to work with outside?
* How does it compare with a Windows TabletPC?
* I'd like to also use this as a general laptop: how well does it work when propped upright? How well does it work with a mouse and keyboard plugged in?
* Any issues with heat?
* What's the battery time like, same as the MacBook?
* How does the GPS work, and will it work with things like a GPS-Map waypoint software (say, route 66 or something?)
* Anything that might cause problems using it as you would a day-to-day laptop?
* I'm worried about how fragile it is; the front cover, from what I've seen, isn't covered when it's transported. Is there some sort of shield so I don't end up with a pencil ruining the Modbook's screen?
* what kind of stylus does it use? Can it use Wacom's other stylii?
* How well does it work with Ink? How well does Ink work, for that matter?

That'll do for a start....
Click to view iJavaJoe's profile New Member 20 posts since
Jan 30, 2006
10. Jan 22, 2007 5:57 PM in response to: daneb
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
If you read the info on the OtherWorld Computing website, you'll see that this is NOT the same screen! The screen they use is not as glossy and has a higher contrast ratio. The size is still 13" and the resolution is the same. Also the resolution of the Wacom digitizer 20x higher then the actual screen resolution, also it's 256 levels of pressure (a bit low if you ask me) 512 or 1024 would be better.
Click to view joewiz's profile New Member 1 posts since
Jan 22, 2007
11. Jan 22, 2007 6:02 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
1. Is this a slate tablet (no keyboard), or a convertible (screen swings open and swivels to reveal internal keyboard)?

2. Will it come with or sell with a stand or dock, so you can use it at a desk (with an external usb or bluetooth keyboard and mouse)?

3. The specs page says wireless is "802.11g" - but presumably it's the same 802.11n-capable card that comes with Core 2 Duo MacBooks?

4. If I lose the stylus, what else works? And how much are replacements?
Click to view Jon Seff's profile Macworld Editorial 697 posts since
Dec 13, 2000
12. Jan 22, 2007 6:22 PM in response to: joewiz
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook
OK, this should keep me busy.


Jon Seff - Senior News Editor, Macworld
Click to view smittst's profile New Member 2 posts since
Feb 22, 2006
13. Jan 22, 2007 6:30 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Re: Editors' Notes Weblog: Answering your ModBook questions

The Questions i have are regarding Apple's Inkwell software itself and how well it functions on the Modbook. How good/bad is it relative to the competition out there and how well does it integrate itself into other programs.
Click to view Schneb's profile Enthusiast 1,271 posts since
Dec 10, 2002
14. Jan 22, 2007 6:44 PM in response to: Macworld.com
Quick Note
Just a quick comment to say that I like the way this article starts. Rather than assume our questions, you ask first, then write your article. So you already have garnered interest, and now anticipation to the follow-up article. Well done!