8.
Mar 20, 2008 10:11 AM

in response to:
Ravary
Re: From the Lab: Optimizing the MacBook Pro
I would have to request a battery test also. I am quite curious about the battery life with a 7200 rpm HDD vs a standard 5400 one. How much of a hit does it take?
RPM is the great myth of drives, so it's too bad RPM is how everybody compares drive performance. Not only can slower RPM drives sometimes outperform faster RPM drives when newer, more information-dense and efficient technologies are used in the "slower" drive, but battery life is also not linear to RPM. A number of studies around the Web show that battery life is not necessarily sacrificed, and may be balanced by faster boot times and other increases in overall efficiency that a faster drive affords. It's kind of like when Bluetooth 2 came out. Sure, it used more power, but the faster speed decreased transfer time so much that you ended up using less net power.
Of course, this always depends on which specific models of drives Apple puts in, but they never tell us.
Here's one test that concludes
Choose the faster drive hard whenever possible.
I'm ordering the 7200 drive for my next MacBook Pro.