Quantcast
You are not logged in, click here to log in.
274 Replies Last post: Jun 30, 2008 6:54 PM by leftj   Go to original post 1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 ... 19 Previous Next
Click to view CSHander's profile New Member 5 posts since
Jan 11, 2006
90. May 27, 2008 8:23 AM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster

I like the new keyboard a lot with one exception. Apple has nearly replaced all of the "white" components in it's case design, the only remaining computer with the color white as part of it's design being the Mac mini. When you put the keyboard in front of an Aluminum iMac, it doesn't look right - like they don't even go together. The keys need to be black, like the accents on the iMac.

I even went so far as to attempt to take the keycaps from a Macbook, but even though the keys are the same style and look, the scissor mechanism and the underside of the keyboard are just different enough to make it not work.

Click to view krzymac's profile New Member 5 posts since
Apr 18, 2007
91. May 27, 2008 8:25 AM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
Seems like the boys at Macworld are bored to tears. The Apple aluminum keyboards is one of the best keyboards my fingers have ever touched. There is by far more pros than cons in this msg center concerning this subject and now the boys at Macworld know how good this keyboard really is. :^0
Click to view TucsonCurt's profile New Member 7 posts since
May 25, 2006
92. May 27, 2008 8:42 AM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
I was just looking over these posts - and the raw nerve Jon seems to have touched. Almost exactly 25% of the posts are negative (including mine). That's a pretty high percentage and something Apple should look into. It may be related to manufacturing QC issues on only some of the keyboards. I miss lots of letters when I type on the aluminum keyboard - especially at the beginning of words. This morning I went back to my nice, thin Macally IceKey keyboard and, boy, the improvement is noticable.
Click to view gballey's profile New Member 26 posts since
Feb 29, 2008
93. May 27, 2008 9:01 AM in response to: folklore
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster

Re: cleaning the Might Mouse scroll ball:

Gee4orce's technique (turning the mouse over and rolling the scroll ball vigorously on the mousepad) is the first thing I try when the scrolling action acts up. That fixes the problem about 9 times out of 10 for me. This might be require twice a week or so.

When that fails to fix it, I use a pre-soaked alcholol tab (they come in a box, each 1-inch square tab individually sealed in an envelope). I use the tab to roll the ball around in all directions as needed. This often dredges up some crud that I can wipe off.

I used a Mighty Mouse for the last couple of years on my old iMac G4 800, and these steps have always returned the scroll ball to full functionality. I even purchased a Bluetooth Mighty Mouse to use occasionally with my MacBook, which I purchased last summer.

As for the aluminum keyboard:

I like the keyboard on my MacBook, which as others have noted is pretty similary to the aluminum keyboard. I'm a touch typist, and I also have arthritis in my fingers. I've found that this style keyboard works very well for me. Just about 3 weeks ago I finally retired my trusty old iMac G4 800 and replaced it with a new 24-inch iMac. Now I have two Macs with virtually the same keyboard, which is great (I still use a Dell keyboard on my PC keyboard at work, too). I also like that fact that I can push the thin keyboard up under the iMac screen on its stand, and still be able to make some use of it, as I frequently have papers or whatever right in front of me on the table.

Click to view k88dad's profile New Member 72 posts since
Mar 22, 2005
94. May 27, 2008 9:38 AM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
I bought the wired version (must have numeric keypad) as a replacement for the keyboard that came with my first gen. 20" iMac C2D. The left control key had collapsed on the white keyboard (Visual Pinball is murder on the keys assigned to flippers.) I'm hoping that the aluminum model will prove to be more durable. Ten months later, I still love it. Zero issues.

Ikea sells some economical computer furniture and they have install-it-yourself keyboard trays for next to nothing. Of course, they may not be Rubbermaid (r) compatible.
Click to view VoxLocus's profile New Member 12 posts since
Feb 20, 2008
95. May 27, 2008 10:01 AM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
What more is there to say than I bought two used "old" white keyboards.

I have several Macs. The MacBook keyboard is the worst because letters often don't register when pushed. The ShinyShiny Aluminized one is the same.

I've also retired my BlueTooth keyboards. (the "old" white models) It was just a pain re-registering them and replacing batteries. The USB version is just fine, thank you, and the "white" keys register when pushed!

Ah, for that old IBM Selectric. What a joy to push a key and hear the ball whack the paper . . .
Click to view DFAJSL's profile New Member 1 posts since
May 27, 2008
96. May 27, 2008 10:57 AM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
We have two 24" iMacs with aluminum keyboards: One has no issues - works as expected. On mine, the right arrow requires a very firm strike to work-which has been a minor adjustment to my typing. Overall: we are happy.
Click to view HALO9X's profile New Member 9 posts since
Jan 2, 2008
97. May 27, 2008 7:59 PM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
I find that the keyboard is very good. In fact I went ahead and bought the Wireless Keyboard and have been very happy with it. My computer desk has a keyboard shelf but the wired version takes up too much space that my mouse needs. The smaller wireless keyboard is perfect for my needs. However, there is one improvement that Apple could make and that is get rid of the mouse altogether. An included mouse pad to both of the keyboards would eliminate the mouse and make the keyboard/mouse an all-in-one of their own which would compliment the unity of the iMac.
Click to view abuerer's profile New Member 3 posts since
Feb 26, 2008
98. May 27, 2008 8:06 PM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
I have been using the aluminum keyboard since August, and I have found it to be the best keyboard that I've ever used. I had long thought that my old iBook had a better keyboard than any stand-alone that I'd seen, but this new aluminum keyboard changed that. Its low profile makes it ergonomically friendly, and its short keys are very easy to press. The don't require as much movement as a more traditional key style, and they give a larger top area to press. Plus, they can only be pressed downward, unlike some keyboards that had a bit of lateral key movement, which would sometimes keep keys from being depressed.
Click to view moose_n_squirrel's profile Old Hand 2,853 posts since
Sep 16, 2004
99. May 27, 2008 9:54 PM in response to: HALO9X
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
HALO9X wrote:
An included mouse pad to both of the keyboards would eliminate the mouse and make the keyboard/mouse an all-in-one of their own which would compliment the unity of the iMac.

This is a great idea, I noticed this too. There are some useful gestures I can do on my laptop trackpad that I miss on the desktop.
Click to view hayesk's profile Member 710 posts since
Aug 7, 2004
100. May 28, 2008 6:54 AM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
Bring back the Apple Extended Keyboard II - the best keyboard made by Apple or anyone! ;-)

Sure, the thing costed $200, but that keyboard had the best tactile feedback I've ever experienced.
Click to view trip1ex's profile Member 182 posts since
Sep 12, 2006
101. May 28, 2008 12:55 PM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
I would have to disagree with the author.

I think the keyboard makes the old one look downright ancient (like when comparing today's iMac with an old G3 iMac.)

The keyboard is also noticeably quieter which is a big bonus if you have 2 kids and a wife and you're on the computer late at night.

Last I would disagree that the keyboard requires more strength to press the keys. I think it's the opposite. I feel like it requires a lighter touch and that I can type faster as a result of that.
Click to view Ruben's profile New Member 3 posts since
May 28, 2008
102. May 28, 2008 2:24 PM in response to: Macworld
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster

Yep, the recording of all the keystrokes has long been a problem with the aluminum keyboard. i've ready many similar gripes in other forums. If we can see this why can't Apple? If they know about it why don't they make available another option as far as a keyboard?

The wireless keyboard is really nice looking but I've heard it's even worse on recording all keystrokes.

Click to view Adammiller's profile New Member 45 posts since
Feb 24, 2008
103. May 28, 2008 2:47 PM in response to: Ruben
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
Its easy to see you you haven't taken a look at the majority of the post on this article. The users reporting problems about the keyboard are the minority and most of us are extreamly happy with them. I for one use the aluminum keyboard at least 8 hours a day at work and usually another hour to two freelancing at home. If it was a dell keyboard acting screwy, you wouldn't even think anything of it... It would be expected.
Click to view Mav's profile New Member 70 posts since
Mar 18, 2005
104. May 28, 2008 2:53 PM in response to: Ruben
Re: Aluminum keyboard loses its luster
For people with keystroke-recording problems -- it just shouldn't be happening, period. Bring it in to an Apple Store or other authorized service provider ASAP and make use of that 1-yr. AppleCare warranty.